Air Fryer or Electric Oven? Which One to Buy for Your Home
The bottom line: If most of your cooking involves potatoes, chicken, and fried food for two to four people, get an air fryer (Kenwood HFP30, or Philips Essential XL for a larger family). If you bake cakes, bread, bechamel trays, and whole chickens, get an electric oven (Tornado 48 liter). And if your kitchen cannot handle two appliances, an air fryer oven like the Kenwood MOA26 does both in small quantities.
Photo: Infrogmation of New Orleans — CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons
The Difference in Working Method and Speed
The air fryer is actually a very small oven: a heating element and a strong fan close to the food, with the food placed in a basket surrounded by hot air. This is why it browns and crisps small quantities quickly. The electric oven has a much larger space, with heating elements at the top and bottom, and many models also feature a fan, accommodating trays, shelves, and a rotisserie skewer.
The air fryer does not need a long preheating time, and its small space allows heat to reach the food quickly, so frozen potatoes, for example, usually finish faster in it than in the oven. The electric oven needs about 10 minutes of preheating before you put the tray in, but it cooks a much larger quantity all at once. And a tip for the air fryer: shake the basket halfway through so the color is even.
Capacity: Which One Fits Your Home?
The air fryer basket is usually from 3.5 to 6 liters, and food must be spread in a nearly single layer so the air can reach it. The electric oven ranges from 25 to 60 liters and more, and takes a full tray.
- The air fryer is better for: French fries, chicken wings, nuggets and paneed items, kofta, roasted vegetables, and reheating taameya and leftover potatoes without them getting soggy.
- The oven is better for: Potato tray with meat, macaroni bechamel, basbousa and cakes, bread and pastries, and a whole chicken on the skewer.
If your family has 5 members and you make potatoes in a 3.5-liter air fryer, you will make them in two or three batches. At that point, an oven or a larger air fryer is more comfortable.
Which One Consumes More Electricity?
A 1500-watt air fryer running for 20 minutes consumes about half a kilowatt-hour. An 1800-watt oven preheats for 10 minutes and then takes half an hour for the tray, so it can approach 1.2 kilowatt-hours, though it is often less because the thermostat cycles on and off. For a small quantity, the air fryer is more economical. But if you are going to make the same tray quantity in the air fryer in 3 batches, the difference drops significantly, and the oven might actually be more economical.
Trays and Accessories
Before you buy an oven, measure the tray you use at home and compare it to the interior dimensions on the sales page. A 45 to 50-liter oven takes an average family-sized tray, and smaller ones take only small trays. In the air fryer, there are cake molds, small trays, and special paper sized for the basket, but leave space around the food so the air can circulate. And do not spray cooking spray directly onto the basket coating; put the oil on the food.
The Middle Ground: Air Fryer Oven
There are small ovens with an air frying mode, like the Kenwood MOA26 (25 liters), which perform the work of a small oven and an air fryer in a single device, suitable for a small kitchen or two to three people. Its drawback is that its capacity is smaller than a 48-liter oven, so a large gathering tray will not fit, and its price category is high relative to its size. If you also need to reheat food, check the electric oven versus microwave comparison, as it includes a convection and air-fry microwave.
Before You Buy
- Make sure the appliance is 220 volts, and check who the seller is: Amazon itself, the brand store, or another seller.
- Local agent warranty is better than an “international warranty,” because the international one might not be accepted at local repair centers here.
- The oven is 1800 watts and the air fryer is from 1500 to 2000 watts, so do not run them together on the same power strip.
- Leave ventilation space around the device as the manual states, and as soon as it arrives, count the trays, shelves, skewer, and basket.
FAQ
Does the air fryer replace the electric oven?
For one, two, or three people, usually yes for frying, grilling, and reheating. But it will not replace the oven if you bake pans of basbousa, cakes, and macaroni bechamel for a family, because the basket will not hold a large tray.
Which consumes more electricity: the air fryer or the electric oven?
For a small quantity, the air fryer is more economical: 1500 watts for 20 minutes is about half a kilowatt-hour, and the oven requires preheating before the food. For a large quantity done in multiple batches in the air fryer, the difference shrinks and the oven might be more economical.
Can I make a cake or basbousa in the air fryer?
Yes, in a small mold sized for the basket, at a temperature about 20 degrees lower than a regular oven and in less time. Start with a small quantity until you get to know your appliance. A large tray requires an oven.
Is the electric oven with a fan the same as an air fryer?
Both cook with hot air, but the air fryer has a small space and the fan is close to the food, so it crisps small quantities faster. The purpose of the oven fan is to distribute heat across a large tray so the baking is even.
Comments
Cooked it? Tell us how it went, or ask a question — we read every comment.